Paget Rangers were made to pay for their mistakes throwing away two points and having to settle for a draw away at basement side Littleton.
The hosts started brightly and could have gone ahead after only two minutes when Luke Rowlands broke clear to beat the keeper only to see his shot hit the inside of the post and spin clear.
The visitors began the second half brightly and only good defensive work kept the score level, but in the 65th minute Paget were awarded a penalty that was converted by Ross Dempster after he had been fouled.
The score was level after 70 minutes when having been bundled over in the area Rowlands converted from the spot.
The game suddenly came to life and after 80 minutes Rangers were back in front after a fine save from Edward Cox rebounded to Torryn Connolly who shot into the top corner.
When all looked lost Littleton showed their desire and were rewarded by an 89th-minute equaliser when Matthew Iorns prodded home from close range after Paget keeper Conal Dowling had spilt the ball from a routine cross.